TV3 Tarik Balik Iklan Raya TV3 2010 Sinari Lebaran
Kenapa mereka tarik balik? semuanya akan terjawab dalam post kali ini. Terkejut bila kali pertama tengok iklan mereka sebab memang terang-terang takde makna islamic langsung. Tak tahu mungkin pengarah iklan ni mungkin bukan muslim sebab kalau muslim, mereka patut bertaubat sebab mencampur-adukkan islam dan semua pegangan lain termasuk kristian, hindu dan illuminati..Masyallah..jom baca kenapa mereka tarik balik dan tadi TV3 minta maaf kepada semua penonton mereka.
Di sini ada beberapa ulasan tentang iklan yang dipaparkan. Sama ada pembaca-pembaca yang bijak sekalian hendak mempercayainya atau tidak, terpulang.
Scene 1 – Budak Lelaki Melayu sedang menilik-nilik sebuah buku bergambar di malam yang gelap dalam sebuah pondok buruk beratapkan rumbia dengan bertemankan sebiji mentol. Terdapat sebuah sangkar burung yang tergantung di sebelah kanan tingk…ap yang terbuka.
1.Budak Lelaki Melayu – Orang Melayu
2.Buku – Bible
3.Pondok Buruk Beratap Rumbia – Kemiskinan
4.Malam Yang Gelap – Islam yang mundur
5.Mentol Lampu – Pencerahan (Illumination) – Lucifer@Iblis6.Sangkar Burung – Simbol manusia yang terkurung dan terkongkong dengan ajaran ISLAM7.Tingkap Terbuka – Jalan keluar dari kemiskinan dan kemunduran
Scene 2 – Close up sehelai mukasurat yang mempunyai gambar sebuah beca bewarna merah dengan berlatarbelakangkan sebuah pokok Krismas dan North Star (Bintang Utara), menutup sehelai mukasurat lain bertulisan JAWI yang diterbalikkan (inverted).
1.Mukasurat Bergambar – Bible (Christianity)
2.Mukasurat Jawi terbalik – Al-Quran yang dihinakan
3.Beca Merah – Samaran untuk kenderaan Santa Claus4.North Star – Bintang Kelahiran Horus (Dajjal)
Pokok Krismas – Simbol Paganism
Scene 3 – Keluarnya bintang-bintang kecil beraura yang membawa cahaya dari gambar beca. Budak Melayu delighted (kagum dan gembira). Bintang-bintang berterbangan keluar dari tingkap rumah buruk lalu membentuk sebuah beca merah berlampu lip-lap dengan seorang lelaki separuh abad yang memakai songkok (bukan ketayap) putih dan berambut putih. Lelaki separuh abad mempelawa budak Melayu untuk bersama-sama menaiki beca merah dan seterusnya meninggalkan pondok buruk.
1.Bintang-bintang kecil beraura – Keajaiban, kekayaan, kemahsyuran, kemodenan etc.
2.Lelaki Rambut Putih Dan Bersongkok Putih – POPE – Ketua Agama Kristian
3.Pelawaan Menaiki Beca – Pelawaan Masuk Kristian
Scene 4 – Budak Lelaki Melayu dengan seorang Budak Perempuan Melayu masuk ke dalam beca dan terus duduk bersandar. (Scene ini memaparkan kejayaan memurtadkan (merosakkan) Bangsa Melayu)
1.Budak Lelaki Dan Budak Perempuan Melayu – Bangsa Melayu.
Scene 5 – Beca terbang ke Pulau Pinang, Teluk Intan, dan Kuala Lumpur. Tempat-tempat ini bercahaya dan bersinar (illuminated) dengan kehadiran beca merah.
1.Pulau Pinang – Tempat Illuminati mula bertapak (Francis Light)
2.Teluk Intan, Hilir P…erak (Anson) – Ada Illuminati Lodge kat sini. Rotary club pun bersepah.
3.Kuala Lumpur – Malaysian Illuminati punya capital.
Scene 6 – Tiba-tiba ada satu pasangan tambahan budak lelaki/perempuan melayu dalam beca.
1.Pasangan Melayu Extra – Murtad dan kerosakan makin berkembang dan mendapat sambutan
Scene 7 – Beca berhenti depan unit kondo. Satu pasangan budak Melayu lagi diorang pickup. Budak Melayu Kampung gembira sampai bercahaya-cahaya mukanya.
1. Kondo – Bandar/Middle Class. Budak kampung dah diterima oleh orang bandar. Masuk Kristian adalah cool, urban, modern dsbnya.
Cuba perhatikan, mengapa perlu ada awan yang ‘menyalib’ setiap menara masjid ini? Kebetulan jugakah ini? Atau memang di setiap menara-menara mana-mana masjid terdapat awan seperti ini?
Apa sebab perlu dipaparkan teratai dalam iklan Aidilfitri sedangkan banyak lagi bunga yang boleh disiarkan. Teratai ini mempunyai bahan yang menyala (pelita) di tengahnya seolah-olah teratai Buddha ketika melakukan upacara keagamaan mereka.
Mungkin gambar ini kelihatan biasa bagi sesiapa yang tidak menyedari tapi secara kebetulan atau tidak, inilah hasil penelitian yang diperoleh..
Rasanya semua sudah makruf tentang bintang 6 bucu yang terpapar bukan? Masya Allah.. Anda punya akal, nilailah kesemua ini dengan akal bijak anda..
Mungkinkah semua ini adalah kebetulan? Banyakkan membaca tentang agenda kafir laknatullah terhadap umat Islam memandangkan iklan ini berkaitan dengan perayaan umat Islam. Ingatlah, Allah berfirman dalam al-Quran: “Tidak akan pernah redha orang2 Yahudi dan Nasrani kerhadap kamu sehingga kamu menuruti telunjuk mereka” (2:120).
Tafsiran dibawakan oleh Kalamul Haqq. Terima kasih..
Baca selanjutnya di:
06 September 2010
Masa 12:20 am
Lama-kelamaan semakin banyak unsur2 yang nak disumbat ke dalam pemikiran kita. Nauzubillah..
[Reply]
wanmus Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 6:09 am
makin lama sikit2 makin teruk
[Reply]
john michhel Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 1:19 pm
kenapa semua orang nak hina agama kristian sedangkan bukan orang kristian yang buat iklan ini….orang buddha yang buat iklan raya ini di sri pentas jadi kalau anda tak tahu apa apa tolong jangan hina orang kristian. adakah orang kristian pernah hina umat islam…itu persoalan saya…….dan tolong maafkan kakitangan tv3.dan saya tahu tv3 tetap the best…..DAN TOLONG JANGAN HINA SEKALI PUN ORANG KRISTIAN ….selamat hari raya aidilfitri…….
[Reply]
Faizal Syukri Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 3:48 pm
orang Islam xhina orang kristian… geng illuminati yang mmg anti ngan semua agama lain termasuk Islam dan kristian.
[Reply]
Konspirasi Mengarut Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 5:15 pm
kenapa cepat percaya teori yang seperti ini. Inilah teori konspirasi yang paling mengarut sekali. ada halaman yang dah counter hujah yang seperti ini
http://beritasemasa.com/illuminati-freemason-disebalik-iklan-raya-di-malaysia
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 12:45 am
hu3.. tv3 sykt illuminati??
terok ar skrg ni.
[Reply]
wanmus Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 6:10 am
xtaulah..mungkin tema 1Malaysia tapi langsung x kena
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 1:42 am
penerangan yg lengkap…thanks..
semoga umat Islam dilindungi Allah
[Reply]
wanmus Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 6:10 am
sgt lengkap..kalau kita, mungkin x nampak
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 1:50 am
Fuhh… penerangan yang sangat teliti skali.. ramai yang mungkin tak perasan tentang semua ni.. Bagus lah kalau ianya dah ditarik balik..
[Reply]
wanmus Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 6:11 am
memang ramai x perasan..tapi xtaulah, tgk yg pelita dalam bunga tu pun dah nampak macam hindu..pelik giler
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 2:51 am
brutal juga tafsiran … brutal dan ada benarnya … ha, siasat la benda2 mcm ni, pihak2 berkuasa .
[Reply]
wanmus Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 6:12 am
dah ada yang hantarkan bantahan, termasuk PAS katanya. tu yang terus tarik balik
[Reply]
sahara Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 10:07 pm
pada pendapat saya, sesuatu itu kalau kita cari yang negatif, kita akan jumpa yang negatif. kalau kita lihat yang positif, kita akan jumpa yang positif. saya x menyokong iklan ini, mungkin pihak tertentu boleh memperbaiki lagi idea ini supaya tidak menimbulkan sesuatu yang menyinggung sensitiviti masyarakat, tetapi dalam masa yang sama, masyarakat lain pula janganlah cepat sangat nk melatah. maybe you are just reading / watching too much into it.
just an opinion.
[Reply]
radd Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 10:38 am
mgkn tafsiran terlalu pesimis atau mungkin jgk unsur2 dimasukkan secara terancang dan teliti. kebetulan ke betul2?
tapi sangat xmungkin otak manusia xdpt fikir ke tak-sesuaian beca ngan teratai tu nk diselitkan dalam sambutan yang dikaitkan dengan AGAMA islam. mana mata2 org yg screen sblm dipamer kpd public? xperasan ke? atau mmg sengaja nk dipamer sbb ade agenda tertentu?
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 3:47 am
macam2 cara dorang buat… erm… orang2 kat stesen tv tu tak prihatin ke… (-_-’)
[Reply]
Malaji Reply:
September 9th, 2010 at 7:52 am
Sallam semua, Setelah iklan yang paling bodoh dihentikan penyiaran oleh Tv3, nampaknya mereka masih degil, Tv3 masih menyelitkan unsur-unsur dakyah yahudi nya dengan menyelitkan gambar bunga AMITHABA dalam iklan hari raya, cuba perhatikan………….
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 7:23 am
Suatu penghinaan yang nyata…dan yang lebih mengecewakan…berjaya mempergunakan ‘orang kita’ dalam menyebarkan dakyah ini.
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 9:35 am
Kebodohan tahap gaban. Kalau nak dijadikan isu semua pun boleh diteliti dan di letakkan unsur lain. Kopiah putih sama dengan pope? Penulis ingat semua orang bodoh macam dia.
[Reply]
su Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 12:02 pm
Tak perlulah kita membodohkan sesiapa. Yang nyata semakin banyak cubaan pihak tertentu untuk melemahkan/menyesatkan umat agama Islam yang suci ini. Jika tidak secara terang/nyata, dibuat secara tersirat. Kalau kita bukan seorang yang peka, jangan biarkan orang lain menjadi seperti kita. Wallahu’alam…
[Reply]
Kelly Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 10:11 pm
Betul kata Robbie. Penelitian yang terlalu asyik dengan idea knospirasi.
Pengarah cuma ingin menyelitkan mesej 1Malaysia. Itu saja penerangan yang simple. Buat apa nak terhegeh-hegeh selitkan ‘isi tersirat’ yang sememangnya hasil imaginasi diri sendiri?
[Reply]
Yang Memerhati Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 4:31 pm
Agenda tertentu sudah pasti…tapi sapa ya???
1Malaysia ke or 1Agama ke..kalau kebetulan
sebab ape kena tebalikan tulisan jawi,
daripada Al-Quran atau tidak kita x tau…tapi yg nayata
itu satu penghinaan…sama seperti jikalau salib diterbalikan.
Ini bukan soal agama mana, ini hasil kerja orang yang x perpagang kepada mana2 agama…ni hasil kerja askar2 Dajjal.
[Reply]
Mzridz1 Reply:
September 22nd, 2010 at 10:09 pm
kalau nak dipandang secara positif, mmg nmpk iklan ni nak dijadikan 1 Malaysia. tp Aidilfitri ni berkaitan ngan agama Islam. tak perlu dicampuradukkan ngan agama2 lain; tak sesuai. kalau Hari Kemerdekaan, ok je
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 11:57 am
Thank you very much for the comment, Robbie. Inilah… INILAH yang dipanggil hasutan.
Tak sensitif ke penulis terhadap org2 lain yang baca entri ini ?
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 2:12 pm
Kalau sekali lalu tengok iklan tu mmg jelas imej beca n teratai tu serupa simbol santa claus n buddha. yang lain2 tu tak jelas kecuali kita pause kat situ. yg jelas iklan tu ada unsur plurarism agama. ia satu cubaan menyamakan semua agama melalui perayaan, deeparaya, kongsiraya, merryraya. unsur2 yg dekat di mata n hati kita digunakan oleh pendokong plurarism agama. hati2 dgn anak2 yg minta gula2 kat santa dan dewa buddha di pasaraya sewaktu perayaan mereka. ianya pemesongan akidah yg condong kepada plurarism.
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 2:55 pm
kEnaPa piHak tErteNtu tak pEka dlm mEnelItI IkLAN sEbeLum disiarkan . . ?
[Reply]
radd Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 10:40 am
kenapa encik xpeka mmbetulkan penggunaan huruf besar kecil? hehe, jgn amik hati. pose kan?
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 2:59 pm
[...] tidak dapat melihat iklan ini di TV3 kerana ia ditarik balik oleh mereka sebelum saya sedar tentang isu ini. Tetapi almaklumlah, memandangkan ini adalah zaman Internet, maka saya dapat [...]
06 September 2010
Masa 3:51 pm
Askum,
Saya x berpihakan sapa2, and i can see the dumbness from both sides. I agree that someone says that it should be removed as we all know, we malaysian mostly not that smart and overly sensitive, so these confusing ads should just not be made at the 1st place, not many people understands it..majority dont! too bad, what to do..
you guys talk as if this malaysia is only made of single origins. what about mixed culture people like me? my dad is chindian (chinese mom, indian dad) and my mom is thai malay…my dad’s side are all mostly catholics, but of course he converted to islam when marrying my mom. We celebrate every festival, Hari Raya bcos we r muslims, xmas bcos of my dad’s side, deepavali bcos of hindu side, chinese new year, for the chinese side..and we take the festivals seriously, till the extend that we actually have xmas tress set up when xmas and house will be like a lighting showroom when raya!
We gather for reunion dinner when CNY, i helped out to build ‘phandel’ for thaipussam every year for the indian friends n family..and i visit my grandparents grave yearly during all souls day and all saints day.
but of course i only pray to islam, and during the other festivities, i just follow for the ‘adat’ and not perform any special praying activities for it, only during my Raya i go and pray jemaah at the mosque and really doing it.
It doesnt cloud my siblings and my mind based on how we are brought up. We are fine, moderate muslims.
I find that if the REAL intention of this Ad is to potray that Islam is moderate and it welcomes and respect other religions, i am DAUN with it! if otherwise, then it shouldnt be made…confusing the majority la brudder..if nak buat nak tersirat sangat tu, buat la normal viral vid post kat youtube ke, ape ke so x semua yg bodoh dapat tengok and be confused. Ada ke badan atau pihak yg ditubuhkan untuk explain maksud ‘positif’ kpd yg majority bangangs ni? dua dua pendapat pun x boleh pakai..kita semua kena ataih pagar and see the positivity on everything…
so back to my perayaan story…so it means i am not a true muslims lah that i celebrate everything?? amd receive presents during xmas?? wrong?? i receive ang pow during CNY wrong?? cannnot mix it up is it?? Lagu-lagu semua korang bukan naik arak lagi menari kat club bila lagu di REMIX kan..tapi bila ada unsur agama diremixkan (islam dipetingkan) untuk positivity tak boleh!!! sensitive!!! tapi org org ni lah yg dok lepak di Centro club tiap2 mlm.
[Reply]
danhua Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 5:08 pm
dumbness of both side?
kalo ko tere, sile buat iklan raye y baru. dan sile ckp melayu. time kaseh.
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 9:12 pm
Well said, friend ! Posts like these only play up sentiments of hatred more than anything else.
[Reply]
sahara Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 10:16 pm
agree.
i think, the actual message is they wanna tell us about the multiple cultures that we have in this country. anyone can celebrate aidilfitri, as much as we(muslims) can celebrate deepavali, chinese new year, christmas and all. it’s just celebrations. we SHARE celebrations. that doesn’t mean we pray to their God or whatever.. it’s just cultures guys..
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 7:14 pm
Do this in the 60′s and 70′s and Malaysians not only marvel at the ads ; they give it a standing ovation.
Do it today and what do you get ? People rejecting it over things which seem rather trivial. But no, that’s only the tip of the iceberg.
The iceberg comes with responses like this post. My heart really aches saying this, but I’ve just gotta.
[Reply]
radd Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 11:02 am
hello, agama xbole campur kan pandai?
[Reply]
ika Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 3:00 pm
Wslam..fadlin, kalu anda betol betol pasti faham akan sensitive ini & kalu betol2 blajar agama islam..sila selidik kembali..apa makna ‘hari raya aidilfitri’..
-Mudahan Allah m’beri p’tunjuk.
[Reply]
xul Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 3:37 pm
Salam Fadlin..
Good explaination… tp sekadar on paper je la.. klo anda kaji, xmas tu sndiri adalah perayaan agama, bukan kebudayaan..sbb tu muslim diharamkan sebenarnya sambut xmas.. CNY yes, kebudayaan, muslim boleh sambut.. masalah skng adalah ramai yg amik mudah tentang definisi agama, budaya, adat… so kaji dulu sblom post/nak mengata ape2..
selamat hari raya aidilfitri
[Reply]
fadlin bodoh Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 4:41 pm
fadlin, anda jangan jadi seperti orang jahil. mende salah tetap salah apa pasal pulak mau jadi atas pagar. bahlol. ko kata iklan tu menunjukkan islam tolerate ngan agama laen? bangang!!!cakap byk x guna la ngan lu. fuck odd
[Reply]
Punjatan Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 11:35 pm
This is the problem with certain people in this country. Have lots of time to find other peoples faults when they should be correcting themselves first instead of nosing around others. Kesian kan? Dulu mak bapak suruh pegi sekolah, tak nak! Buat cerita nak menghasut pandai!! Uneducated fool!
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 2:20 pm
I thank you Punjatan !
[Reply]
tenang Reply:
September 9th, 2010 at 7:11 am
Inilah jadinya bila org yg jahil,bercakap tentang agama.Jauhkan dari segala bala dan malapetaka.Allah Maha Besar
[Reply]
yang gelengkepala... Reply:
September 12th, 2010 at 3:10 pm
haiii…apa nak jadi la. cuba la hangpa fikir..suke ker org lain pijak pala kite? Agama tu patot di muliakan..dijunjung,bukan dikelek, dihina mcm ni..aku tak setuju la…konsep satu malaysia tu lebih pada perpaduan masyarakt, integrity kenegaraan dlm warganegara ni,yang ni boleh la buat iklan macam lagu ni. hari raya untuk yang beragama islam jer…bila masa lak raya aidilfitri ni boleh diamalkan agama lain???? islam bukan budaya. penganut agama lain boleh raikan sama2 jer..nak makan apa makan la…kujung menginjung tu da kira adat. boleh tak krang bezakan akidah dengan yang lain2? iklan ni pon maju tak bertempat…bila tengok, tak tercuit pon perasaan kami. rasa pelik ade la..iklan sekarang tak best. malam raya ti bebudak tunggu beca nak balik kampung..rosak minda anak2. ‘tak dapat la nak imagine bila nak raya…kami mak bapak sibuk kemas rumah…anak2 sibuk tanya ” abah tak pasng pokok krismas ke?” naya kan? yang xsetuju dgn saya..xper, tapi saya xkn benarkan sedara mara saya buta dan tak tahu unsur2 perosak akidah pulak…biar kecil2 lagi mereka tahu dan dapat bezakan.
[Reply]
TYNA Reply:
September 24th, 2010 at 4:17 pm
Cik Fadlin, sekiranya benar kita Islam, maka hati, jiwa dan nafsu kita akan menolak segala yg berunsur kekufuran. Hati kita sepatutnya ada rasa takut dan harap kepada Tuhan, kerana perasaan inilah yang sepatutnya ada pada orang Islam seluruhnya tidak kira di Timur ataupun di Barat. Semoga Cik Fadlin sentiasa berada dalam redha Ilahi untuk menuju jalan yang benar…amin.
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 4:38 pm
Allahu akbar
[Reply]
red b Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 7:08 am
Assalamualaikum,
Bersangka baiklah. Why don’t you interpret the iklan, as just an iklan?
FYI, the original blogger who made this dumb analysis is using a bamboo wallpaper for his blog. That doesn’t mean he comes from china or japan or ashinto practioner. A lot of assumptions can be made it also depends on the level of thinking of that person!
When this kind of analysis is interpreted by dumb malays ( i am a malay and muslim ), its just playing on old malay muslim sentiments. Islam mengajar kita untuk menghormati sesama manusia dan bersangka baik. Why can’t the writer do the same?
the worst part is blogger samakan songkok putih dengan pope. habis atuk2 kat kampung pi masjid tu nak dibunuhnye la kot?
[Reply]
fadlin bodoh Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 4:44 pm
ko ni lagi bangang!xpenah aku jumpe org bangang macam ko!mende2 yg dia kaji tu mmg wujud org bahlol mcm ko je x sedar!bersangka baik pala butoh bapak hang!iklan tu menghina agama!puki!
[Reply]
Kelly Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 10:17 pm
RED B, the things you say make absolute sense. Ignore messages like this fadlin guy.
(Yeah, the Pope is on this too (rolls eyes)
[Reply]
dina Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 12:34 pm
author blog ni saje carik yg negative. org melayu mmg xde keje laen selain nk jatuh kn org lain.
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 2:20 pm
^ And no thanks to people like this author, we are suffering from severe subtle ethnic cleansing.
Don’t believe ? BELIEVE IT.
[Reply]
TYNA Reply:
September 27th, 2010 at 3:34 pm
Jangan sesekali hina orang Melayu. Aku sayang bangsaku…jangan cuba memprovokasikan perkara tersebut, wahai Dina…buruk padahnya nanti!
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 4:42 pm
Hish! TV3 dah jadi alat tunggangan freemason. Habislah melayu kita.
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 5:01 pm
Salam,
bagus penulis terangkan dgn terperinci, adakah kebetulan atau sememangnya di rancang? jika kebetulan, tidakkah menjadi fitnah? serius saya tak ske pakcik haji bersongkok putih tu di sama kan dengan POPE christian, tak masuk akal langsung..
ape2 pon, yg baek kite ambil yg buruk kita sisihkan
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 5:24 pm
the way they relate 6 dews (water droplet) as a 6-edged star is so absurd and entertaining, i can draw the same star on a person face using specific coordinates – 1 point at the forehead, eyes as 2 points, 2 points at the cheeks, 1 point at the chin. GG. Tarik balik semua manusia then?
the choices of how these pictures can have their ambiguity interpreted is so limited, that’s just your self centered and overly sensitive point of view.
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 9:09 pm
See reply below – I only just noticed that there was a reply button ^_^’
[Reply]
dina Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 12:36 pm
interpretation 6 dews tu yang paling bodoh skali!
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 5:37 pm
your way: buku – bible
my way : buku – story book
your way: Pondok Buruk Beratap Rumbia – Kemiskinan
my way : Pondok Buruk Beratap Rumbia – traditional houses
your way: Malam Yang Gelap – Islam yang mundur
my way : Malam Yang Gelap – A peaceful area during the night
your way:Sangkar Burung – Simbol manusia yang terkurung dan terkongkong dengan ajaran ISLAM7
my way : Sangkar Burung – A place the bird thing is good for making a nest.
your way: Tingkap Terbuka – Jalan keluar dari kemiskinan dan kemunduran
my way : Tingkap Terbuka – need ventilation
your way: Mukasurat Bergambar – bible
my way : Mukasurat Bergambar – story book with pictures
your way: Mukasurat Jawi terbalik – Al-Quran yang dihinakan
my way : a page looked from behind due to penetrating lights.
your way: Beca Merah – Samaran untuk kenderaan Santa Claus
my way : Beca Merah – Red colour beca
just an example. see? there are many many other ways how u can interpret this pictures. So don’t restrict your choices to those very sensitive ones only.
[Reply]
Me. Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 9:04 pm
I like the way you see it. I agree with you – it depends on the perspective. We see what we want to see…
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 9:35 pm
Those people who tries to restrict others’ perspective, to very sensitive ones, are those who are trying to fry up a religious and racial suggestive dispute.
I hate them, because I respect the idea – 1Malaysia.
[Reply]
xxy Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 12:22 am
i am sure that you ‘the anonymous’ is a non-muslim !!!!!
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 4:04 pm
and? what are u implying?
if the topic is saying “Advertisement pulled back due to the lacking in islamic contents” I will agree. But if u phrase it “Advertisement pulled back due to lacking in islamic content + promoting other religion + insulting Islam” no way that make sense. The guy posted this is obviously trying to stir up a racket and causea a dispute.
[Reply]
Kelly Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 10:20 pm
Absolutely agree Anonymous. One needn’t be Muslim to see that. The so called analysis was hilarious – the only reason I read on. But the brain-washing is ridiculous.
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 2:22 pm
It’s like I told several people ; I’ll be telling it here : I’m okay with people pointing out what shouldn’t be there. But I am NOT okay with people belittling the faiths of others.
Get MCCBCHST to step in ! Get MyConsti to step in. No seriously, if they wanna say their rights were violated, I can say OURS were !
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 8:39 pm
totally agree with post above, jgn cepat melatah, sumpah boleh jadi fitnah..
[Reply]
ika Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 3:04 pm
klu setiap benda d’amik remeh..tggu menanti d’jajah je nt.., xperlu tegak benang yg dah sememangnya basah. terima kasih.
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 9:08 pm
@TheAnonymous : Thanks SO MUCH for the comment, it was well needed.
I mean seriously, like I posted in reply, a white skullcap (kopiah) does not give papal notions as much as bleeding in church and coming in with one’s nothingness (ahem ahem !) denotes blasphemy. Meaning, they just don’t. I’ve seen far too many images where people wear white kopiahs ; come OFF IT. What is the writer trying to do ? Rouse the ignoramus ?
Sad to say, but even Karyaneka and some of the works that I’ve read in similar magazines (which are meant to be informational content) play along the same lines of raising sensitive issues.
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 10:02 pm
Salam.
Kalau nak lakar, buat dengan jelas, sesuai dengan budaya agama islam- beraya dengan pakaian sut melayu, jubah ke, de rendang dodol ketupat yg biase jer. ape kena nak lukis pondok, burung dlm sangkar, tulisan Quran terbalik(cermin reflek), beca, teratai dll. . . Semua ni tak perlu langsung, takde mengena dengan perayaan Islam pun. Betul bengap yang melakar dan yang menyiarkan di tv. Sesuatu nak dipertonton umah berjuta biarlah de etika dan nilai keimanan. Yg melakar memang tuli buta kayu. Berurusan sipandir bengap dan haprak tu memang menyesatkan. Bab agama berikan pada yang arif jangan bagi kat sidungu, bahaya. Sipandir dungu ni main sapu je bukan kenal halal haram, semua semacam je sapu bersih. Ni depa ni salah asuhan.
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 10:25 pm
@MUSI: yes, u may sound right, but that doesn’t mean all those bits and pieces of the ad are promoting other religions. Book = bible? white hair + white hat = pope?, humour me there. They can just say, “the ad is not fully themed abt Hari Raya”. But they should never phrase it the other way, “This raya ad is promoting other religions and partially insulting islam.” Remember,(not promoting), and (not promoting + promoting something else + insult) is two different things. One is just lacking in content, the other one can cause racial dispute. Get ur facts right before talking like the above topic was absolutely right.
[Reply]
xxy Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 12:28 am
you again ??? don’t you get it ?? this is muslim and our religion’s issue ! it has nothing to do with you , the non-muslim ! Besides , this is our eid not yours …..
[Reply]
Unknown Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 10:25 am
So what? You have just shown how close-minded you are, and just not accepting the fact. You said he don’t get it, you just don’t get what he means in the first place.
[Reply]
radd Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 11:10 am
ngok
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 3:54 pm
XXY, ur understanding abt my statement seemed to be totally impaired, yes, the ad is about raya, it have nothing to do with my practices. But what concerned me is not the ad, is how the author brought about this topic cirticizing the ad, claiming it to be (not promoting islamic sentiments + promoting other religions’ sentiments + partly insulting your religion). But from what I see, this ad is just (not promoting enough islamic sentiments), it has nothing to do with promoting others religions or insulting ur religion. His assumption might mislead others and cause more misunderstanding.
I CRITICIZED THE WAY HOW THIS TOPIC SLANT TOWARDS BEING SENSITIVE AND BEING RACIAL SUGGESTIVE. THE WAY THIS TOPIC IS PHRASED or IS ASSUMED TO BE, IS PRONE TO STIR UP DISPUTE, WHICH IT SHOULDNT HAVE.IT WILL CAUSE ALOT OF UNNECASSARY MISUNDERSTANDINGS.
p/s: you’re the one who dun get it XXY
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 4:20 pm
if it’s too hard for u to understand, take this example:
-
A story book might not be a content promoting Islam, but it doesnt mean, the story book MUST be a bible, which you claim it is promoting christianity, therefore it is insulting Islam.
[Reply]
BG Reply:
September 9th, 2010 at 1:10 am
Well said. Whoever doesn’t get what you explained with such an objective mindset really are just dumb and will get side-effects like a headache.
If the ad is lacking something, say it’s lacking something. Why does the interpretation have to do with other beliefs/religion insulting us?
Give me a children’s story book and I’ll tell you where it is lacking certain moral values, AND where it contains the world’s worst curse words. GET IT?
I’ve just wasted my time reading this blog and replying. I just want to show that not all of us are this dumb to just fully accept the content of this article.
[Reply]
xul Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 4:34 pm
XXY, tu la org kate, ckp ngan org xpaham buat kite sakit kepala… dieorg nampak dari segi iklan tu je, maksud tersirat dieorg xkan nampak nye, cayela.. Allah da berfirman, cam penulis sertakan… “Tidak akan pernah redha orang2 Yahudi dan Nasrani kerhadap kamu sehingga kamu menuruti telunjuk mereka” (2:120). So kepada sadare muslim, sentiasa la kite ingat-mengingati, rancangan2 musuh Allah utk melemahkan Islam ni selalu je ade, we all juz need to beware.
aku tau lepas ni ape yg aku post ni kene simbah balik… bese la tu, mmg susah nak ckp ngan org yg xkan paham ni heh…
[Reply]
muslimah Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 10:06 pm
just to say something here . the writer just want u to see the very small and deep meaning about every single scene . and dia bukan bandingkan dengan realiti . hey , open up ur mind . just focus on this specific scope for awhile . dia juga nak terangkan bahawa betapa melayu sekarang ni sudah banyak sangat terdedah dengan agama lain . ulasan penulis ni untuk kita semua fikir dan menyedarkan diri kita . btw , before u talk about something that involves islam , tolong kaji dalam2 .
islam tidak sama dengan agama lain . islam tak boleh di’mix’ kan . kalau tak ape guna kita solat ? bukankah solat tu untuk membezakan agama islam dengan yang lain2 . tolong sedar hakikat ini . sebagai orang islam kita harus sedar dan peka akan masalah ini . ini bukan mainan . maybe some ppl take this lightly . but if u are the true muslim , u’ll take it seriously .
tolong kaji sesuatu jangan hanya menggunakan otak . tapi menggunakan akal atas dasar islam .
wassalam .
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 14th, 2010 at 3:35 pm
I think this is gonna be the umpteenth time this is repeated, but let me make my stance clear :
I am okay with the writer pointing out what’s wrong, and what shouldn’t be in the ad.
I am NOT okay with the bigotry he practises in this article.
C’mon, seriously, what happened to the whole concept of “love your neighbour” ? What happened to “treat others how you wanna be treated” ? Let me tell you, as a Christian and a strong believer in what I just said, I’m not okay if someone belittles my faith. The same goes for you. The thing is that TV3 – MEDIA PRIMA of all bodies – had the decency to take back the ad when it was hurting some Muslims’ sentiments. I’m actually fine with that, and I salute TV3 for what they did. But now look ! If you’re not gonna leave it be, if bigotry is going to be practised in the name of religion, then God bless Malaysia – I’m not saying this in despair, but I am indeed sad over what is happening.
Comments like these, let me tell you, comments and articles like these are the very things that ruin our foundation.
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 10:29 pm
apakah ini secara kebetulan
atau sengaja ingin memperlekehkan agama islam…..
itu satu pertanyaan yang selalu bermain di kotak fikiranku
aper yang terang-terang merosakkaan agama islam adalah…QURAN…QURAN adalah kalam ALLAH dan ianya satu MUKJIZAT yang paling AGUNG…jagalah ia dengan sebik-baiknya
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 10:33 pm
Get a life people. Dah kena tarik iklan sudahlah tu. Depa dah tau what ticks Malaysian muslim.
Baik pi baca quran ka, sembahyang tahjud ka. Analysis macam ni tadak guna. Orang semua satu malaysia dah tau iklan ni tak elok.
Buat pa waste time tulih analysis scene by scene lebih lebih.
Yang penting niat kita tu.
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 6th, 2010 at 10:38 pm
Yes, agree with you, i respect the concept 1Malaysia, harmony and understanding between one another is priceless. But analysis like this which is so racial suggestive, no way, it defeats the idea of 1Malaysia.
[Reply]
muslimah Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 10:10 pm
ye , kalau anda sokong 1 malaysia . bagus . tapi , jangan ambil yang negatif . ambil yang positif . jangan la biarkan mata dikaburi penipuan palsu yang dibangkitkan oleh pemimpin2 kini .
wassalam
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 14th, 2010 at 3:39 pm
What is false ? If I hold my beliefs to be the gospel truth, and you hold yours to be the gospel truth, then where is THE right ?
All the leaders wanna do is unite us. The ad-makers had this in mind. But they did it the wrong way. They already did you guys a favour by taking back the ad. Now enough of giving them flak, I say ! If they are not going to be treated as persons, if the rest of us Malaysians – especially believers in Christ – are not going to be treated as persons, let me tell you, that belief we’re holding is just going to head for a direct crash !
[Reply]
06 September 2010
Masa 11:44 pm
Salam.
Sapa yang melakukan sesuatu yang tak kena kita kena tegur. agar lain masa berwaspada. masalah nya sengaja nak buat sebab. Nak promot hari raya patuhi lah konsep dan tatacara yang baik, prinsip ukuwah dijaga. Jika semua ok tiada sapa nak tegur. Ditegur sebab de cacatnye.
Wallahu a’lam.
[Reply]
07 September 2010
Masa 12:25 am
salam.. pendapat aku mmg dorang nk manipulasi fikiran orang islam.. full stop.
[Reply]
07 September 2010
Masa 9:45 am
Kalau saya jadi Menteri Penyiaran, saya akan rasa malu yang teramat sangat dan minta siapa yang bertanggungjawab dikenakan hukuman yang setimpal.
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 3:57 pm
why must the person be judged? Because the advertisement doesn’t have enough Islmaic sentiments. Or because the advertisement doesn’t have enough Islamic sentiments and is promoting other religions? If you think it was the 2nd way, you’re wrong, that’s just the topic starter’s self-centered point of view.
[Reply]
muslimah Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 10:15 pm
the anonymous , anda mungkin ingin menegakkan konsep 1 malaysia itu . tapi cara ini ternyata salah . apakah agama anda ? jika anda seorang muslim , anda harus mengkaji agama ini dengan lebih mendalam . islam punya maruah . islam agama teragung . tolong peka keadaan ini . tolong hormat sensitiviti muslim2 yang ingin bersama2 menegakkan kebenaran dan kesucian islam .
wassalam
[Reply]
07 September 2010
Masa 11:06 am
WanMus… memang sah nko takde keje lain nak buat. Orang duduk opis buat keje yang diamanahkan, nko perabis bulan posa study iklan cari tengok pelakon mana rambut putih serupa Pope.
Macam mana melayu nak maju?>\
[Reply]
muslimah Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 10:18 pm
jangan fikir hanya dari sudut bangsa melayu . jika kita tak kaji bnd2 ni , macam mana islam nak buka mata ? mahu ke melayu maju tapi islam mundur ? sebelum membuat apa2 kenyataan tolong fikir . inilah tanda akhir zaman . gunakan sisa baki hidup kita untuk tegakkan islam . kalau tak berani guna hujahan dengan hati pun boleh . alang2 kita ada ada alam cyber , kita boleh sebarkan islam dengan lebih maju kan ?
wassalam
[Reply]
07 September 2010
Masa 11:21 am
MENGIKUT LOGIK SAUDARA2 MELAYU YANG AMAT ALIM LAGI BIJAKSANA, KENAPA TAK CADANGKAN DIHARAMKAN SAJA SEBARANG IKLAN ATAU BABAK YANG MELIBATKAN UPACARA BERSANDING?
HARAMKAN PULUT KUNING DITAYANGKAN.
ITU SEMUA ADAT HINDU TU.
TU HA.. ADAT BAGI DUIT RAYA DALAM ANGPOW, BUKAN KE ITU IKUT ADAT CINA? APA, NAK HARAMKAN SEMUA IKLAN RAYA YANG ADA ADEGAN BAGI DUIT RAYA DALAM SAMPUL?
Kesempitan pemikiran Melayu sekarang amat mengagumkan.
Anda semua bagaikan ada penyakit allergy… nampak beca merah terbang, terus nak bengkak kepala hotak fikirkan dakyah kristian yang pesongkan minda anda yang lemah.
[Reply]
ika Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 3:09 pm
masalah sekarang..mana pergi pengertian ‘hari raya aidilfitri’ sebenar!! kembali kepada fitrah.
Kalu semua benda d’amik remeh..
tgu masa Tuhan tu nak tunjuk..?
Come On, jgn jadi Islam yg Jahil.
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 4:24 pm
Watch what you’re saying,from what MAN KUANTAN have said, it doesnt mean MAN KUANTAN is not faithful to his religion. He’s just saying u guys are too narrow minded. The ad might lack Hari Raya related content, but it doesnt mean, it is using Christianity, Budhism and other religion to insult your Religion. Those are the authors wild and self-centered assumptions.
Why cant u guys get it?
[Reply]
muslimah Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 10:55 pm
man kuantan cuma fikir dari sudut melayu .
tolong fikirkan dari sudut islam sendiri . ye , yang ini kita nampak jelas . disebabkan itu ramai muslim terdetik dan sensitif tentang iklan ini . kita sendiri sudah tahu kenderaan terbang berwarna merah sama seperti perayaan kristian . masalah persandingan contohnya , masih ramai lagi melayu beragama islam yang jahil tentang pengharamanya . disebabkan itu , ramai yang tidak sensitif hal itu . ini juga membuktikan melayu sekarang ramai yang jahil tentang agama yang mereka anuti dan ramai yang dah terpengaruh dengan budaya2 luar islam . seharusnya kita , muslim bersama-sama bangun berganding bahu mengelakkan perkara ini berlaku . jika sesama islam sendiri sudah ada pertelingkahan begini , bagaimana kita mahu bangunkan agama2 lain . kami bukan nak cakap man kuantan not religious enough . tapi yang saya nak tegaskan kat sini ialah ,
KITA JANGAN HANYA MENILAI DARI SUDUT BANGSA MELAYU . STATUS BANGSA TAK MEMBANTU KITA DALAM KUBUR PUN . TAPI KITA HARUS MENILAI ATAS DASAR DAN PERSPEKTIF ISLAM . HANYA ITU YANG BAKAL MEMBANTU KITA.
wassalam
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 9th, 2010 at 8:43 am
I dah kata berulang kali… I’m okay dengan penulis mengatakan apa yang tak patut ada. I am not okay bila dia mengutuk orang agama lain.
And let me tell you kalau you teruskan pandangan macam ni, dalam seribu tahun pun you takkan maju.
[Reply]
muslimah Reply:
September 9th, 2010 at 3:04 pm
sebenarnya kalau muslim sendiri pandai mengikut konsep islam boleh je nak maju . cuba tengok zaman nabi dulu . sahabat2 semua ikut syariat , pandangan dan konsep islam maju je . malah para saintis barat pun mengakui . masalahnya sekarang , ramai yang tak ikut dasar islam dah . tu sbb tak pernah maju . ramai yang dah terpesong . lagi satu , penulis bukan nak mengutuk atau nak burukkan agama lain . penulis cuma nak sedarkan umat islam sahaja . sememangnya benda ni semua dah terlebih dahulu diperkatakan oleh rasulullah . di dunia ni mungkin islam tak semaju agama lain . tapi , dunia ni hanya sementara . yang kekal di akhirat sana nanti . di sana islam lah agama yang paling maju dan paling diangkat oleh Allah S.W.T . maaf jika comment saya ini ada menyinggung sesiapa . saya tidak mampu menyedarkan umat islam secara besar-besaran . saya hanya mampu menyedarkan dengan cara ini . tolonglah bangkit wahai umat islam . towanikkusu , semoga anda mendapat hidayah dari-Nya .
wassalam
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 14th, 2010 at 3:30 pm
Remember one thing.
Jenis kamu dan jenis aku telah berjalan bersama-sama sebagai saudara. If you want to separate us, fine. Kalau kamu ingat bahawa saya ini bahaya terhadap korang semua, fine, oust me out of the country. Tapi saya takkan benarkan orang-orang seperti penulis memaki hamun kepercayaan saya !
And just so you know, saya orang Nasrani.
[Reply]
07 September 2010
Masa 11:23 am
stop. sape gado dia bodo! cbe pikir, iklan tu dh xde, dh kne trk blk tapi melayu dok gado2 cm bodo. tergelak je sape yg buat iklan tu tgk hasilnye kt bangse kite.
org ckp iklan tu xsesuai – tarik balik.
iklan camtu xpatut berulang – kita tengok camane.
ape nk gaduh lg?
(emo sket lps surf net tgk bangse kite haru balah same sndiri disebabkan iklan nih. sori yek)
[Reply]
wanmus Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 1:26 pm
tu lah pasal. kalau iklan tu betul, kenapa diorang tarik balik. betul x? so dahlah..iklan tu dah ditarik balik. semoga jadi panduan untuk orang lain nak wat iklan pasni
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 2:28 pm
About TV3 taking back the ad, I’m fine with it. About your accusation of “Christianity being about coolness” is just one of the many insults you’ve thrown to us. You’re quite fortunate, indeed, that we are actually bearing it, giving, giving, giving, the MORE we get insulted like this. No, seriously. Whilst I’m okay with you pointing out things which shouldn’t be there, I am NOT okay with you stating it in a way which belittles other faiths.
So what happens to our whole anti-racialism campaign, huh ? From what I see in these comments, as well as in this article, it’s just a farce ! Just a PLAIN, SIMPLE, BLOODY FARCE !
Thank you lah for ruining this whole thing. I’m not going to hesitate to say it out loud, but I am speaking for Malaysians who want 1Malaysia to exist.
[Reply]
07 September 2010
Masa 3:23 pm
Apa yang paling pelik di dalam iklan diatas ialah berkenaan dengan adegan beca terbang yang amat mirip dengan apa yang selalu kita lihat dikala sambutan hari natal. Pada aku itu isu utamanya. Dan menurut Islam ianya semeanya salah sebagaimana maksud hadis rasulullah pernah bersabda.
” Sesiapa yang menyerupai sesuatu kaum maka dia adalah daripadanya”
Sama jugalah dengan perbuatan-perbuatan lain di hari raya. Sekiranya ia mirip ataupun bercanggah dengan islam maka hukumnya tetap salah. Boleh dibaca sedkit perkongsian disini:
http://blog.nuaeman.com/fikrah/jangan-biarkan-adat-membayangi-ibadat-kita-di-aidilfitri.html
Berkenaan dengan hal-hal lain sebagaimana yang dinyatakan penulis di dalam artikel diatas ianya hanya satu penafsiran daripada pengkaji hal-hal konspirasi freemason dan iluminati. Boleh jadi benar dan boleh jadi tidak.
[Reply]
EP Reply:
September 7th, 2010 at 10:51 pm
nak tambah…. mari kita lihat secara logik, kita ini menyambut Aidilfitri, Aidilfitri untuk orang islam dan kesemua orang melayu adalah islam, orang melayu islam ada tatacara untuk sambut Aidilfitri.. kalau tengok iklan tersebut tiada langsung menunjukkan budaya melayu malah sekali lihat pun kita tahu ianya bukan budaya melayu tapi budaya lain.. rasa-rasa kalau la semua pelakon tu pakai baju biasa, agaknya jadi iklan apa?
[Reply]
07 September 2010
Masa 4:36 pm
[...] advertisement No doubt that is offensive, at least to me. And not because of the crappy reasons listed here on several Malay blogs….I don’t buy it. I certainly do not believe in any conspirary [...]
07 September 2010
Masa 11:10 pm
ia cume eklan…bukan nak kate sapot orang kape…tapi kite sendiri yg bodo…banyak pikir negetif…beca merah…asal berkenaan merah je santa claus….bodo nye orang sapot tu…mbeca merah melambang kan usaha yg berat untuk memaju kan malaysia…dalam bendera malaysia pon ade warne merah kan….jangan la jadi bodo…..bnyak2 kan solat…banyak2 kan doa….supaye diri sendri selamat….jgan pikir nk rosak kan hak orang je….bukan murah nak buat eklan…korang beli mercun tuk anak2 ak..?beli kan…kaloou x beli pon meti anak mintak duet nk beli tampa memberitahu kemahuan nye,…..kan membazer…tapi utk gembire kat anak2 sempene raye…kite sanggup berkorban…same la macam orng yg buat eklan nie….nk raye….korban masa,duet otang macam2 lagi….uuntk gembira kan masyarakat….tapi separuh masyarakat buat taik…jangan buat taik la….allah ta suka tau….dosa besar….kalau ye nk sedar kan orang pon…jangan la generel sgat…macam korang tau ak….semue sardin kat malaysia nie dperbuat daripada katak…aaa…tekejut…..tp knpe dye tanak sebar kan…?semue nie saje nk rosak kan islam…kite sbgai islam kene banyak pikir positif…..jgan jadi kafir…..
[Reply]
Unknown Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 7:17 pm
I like your way of thinking. This should be the ideal way of thinking, look from others’ perspective and not only what we think.
BM
Saya setuju dengan fikiran anda. Ini patutlah fikiran yang betul, tengok juga dari aspek2 yang berbeza dan bukan setakat fikiran diri sendiri.
[Reply]
08 September 2010
Masa 8:30 am
iklan nih? aku x stuju langsung. pandangan masing2 la. setiap perkara pasti ade perdebatan dan ade bersebab. skali tengok pun dh boleh agak. musykil pun ade. kenapa buat mcm ni? mesti korang terfikir punya. takkan nk wat konsep 1M kot. agak2 la. hariraya hanya untuk org ISLAM. jgn di campur aduk dgn budaya dan agama lain. bg aku, iklan ni bkn nk hina KRISTIAN, tp ISLAM tak boleh di campur aduk dgn unsur agama lain. fikirkan lah.
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 2:24 pm
Itu I faham. Yang mereka tarik balik, at least TV3 is sensitive towards others. Tapi to say that Christianity is of the feeling of “coolness” ? HELLO. That is the biggest insult you can give another religion. Kalau MCCBCHST step in, surely diorg akan marah. Because this is not the way to write.
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 3:01 pm
@BUDAKCOOL: Listen closely, the analisis was just overly sensitive.
-
Books = Bible? So means all library in Malaysia are promoting christianity, therefore neglecting Islam?
-
Orang rambut putih + topi putih = pope. So all the old people at the seaside with a white hat, are christian leaders?
-
Beca merah = Santa’s sleigh? So all melacca is the place where Santa sleighs around?
-
6 water droplets = 6 edged stars? So all our faces, 1 point at fore head, eyes as 2 points, 2 points at the cheek, and 1 point at the chin (all together 6 points) = 6 edge stars too, so all human with such faces who go into the mosque are promoting christianity, therefore are not respecting islam? LOL, humour me please.
-
If that’s the case, i think Malaysia will be chaotic because of all these disputes. Think rationally before making a nonsensical accusation please.
[Reply]
Yang Memerhati Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 4:45 pm
You sound so confident…i doubt you’re a muslim.
Before you LOL much louder…just look around you & don’t be so ignorant.
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 6:03 pm
So if u agree to the analysis, u mean u do agree that all books = bible? So books in the libraries are all bible? means all libraries in Malaysia are promoting Christianity?
-
If you agree, I was gona LOL at the sense of humour u posses.
-
Just look around you, find these daily examples (Library full with books, Melacca with lots of red beca, white haired guys with white hat), dont be so ignorant. I humbly return those words of urs back to u, u appeared to be needing it more than I do, plz don’t be a hypocrite.
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 6:04 pm
and what you’re implying? do u mean that if I am a muslim, i must view all books = bible? Bullshit.
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 6:45 pm
If you’ve seen my reply to Wanmus above, I’m okay with people pointing out what shouldn’t be in the ad. But I AM NOT okay with what insults people do towards other faiths. And let me get this straight right now ; this author was playing up the sentiments of disrespect when he did that.
Now this is not a question about who’s gonna laugh last. No one should. Not in MY. Not in a multiracial, multireligious society.
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 6:52 pm
yea,and that hypocrite “Yang Memerhati”, who was such narrow minded, said that I’m being ignorant? I’m not looking around my surroundings?
-
It’s because I wasn’t ignorant, it’s because I looked at what’s happening around me, thats why I am telling him, not ALL BOOKS = bible. He call this ignorant?
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 7:08 pm
Psh, I really hate speaking against other people, but if he reads this, let him know who this is coming from. He really needs to GAL.
And by getting a life I really mean ceasing to think in this manner.
Yes, the world is filled with its dangers, but these dangers weren’t even intended by the advertising team in the first place.
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 7:17 pm
nice way of phrasing, “the world is filled with its dangers, but these dangers weren’t even intended by the advertising team in the first place.”
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 7:20 pm
*cough cough* This was my train of thought. ^_^’
08 September 2010
Masa 2:25 pm
So the conclusion : 1Malaysia is killed just because of the sentiments of a few people who have been provoked. Hmph, where’s the sense in all this ? I think I know just what to write in Uncyclopedia when I have the chance.
[Reply]
maya Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 4:32 pm
for the first time sy tgk iklan..ini pun saya dpt lihat… something wrong…somewhere…so nahhh… terbukti..memang ada keburukan..jugak iklan nih… yg buatnyer pun non muslim… dia main taram jeh lah ikut agama n budaya dia… tp Ad mubarak..merupakan “agama”… belajo..le dulu korang dlm2..ilmu agama..nih..jgn main sokong jeh.. bahaya..jiwa dan bangsa..huhuuu
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 6:07 pm
The keburukan, is it doesn’t have sufficient islamic content. NOT because it was promoting christianity, get it? I DO AGREE to a certain extent that the ad was inappropriate as a Raya ad due to lacking in islamic content. But i WON’T AGREE AT ALL that the ad is trying to promote Christianity.
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 6:52 pm
To be honest, Anon, when the author wrote that, my heart really ached.
Let me put it on record that I am a Catholic Christian, and I have family members who are Muslims and Sikhs. The whole point of my existence is to treat others in love, even if it hurts. And I’m not the kind who believes that faith should be “cool”. In fact, the people who turn away from church, as I have seen, believe that we’re uncool. It’s a question about orthodoxy and orthopraxy. If both of these aren’t there, then faith in practice would lose its meaning, right ?
So when he wrote that… I didn’t know what to feel. I know some articles being written like that elsewhere. I’m just thankful Mingguan MStar didn’t follow in their footsteps.
To put it straight, almost nothing promotes Christianity as far as the media is concerned. Everything seems to be going apart as though this is a “post-Christian” era. That having been said, I doubt the ad would even wanna promote us. But that’s not the point. The point is whatever the situation, these sentiments shouldn’t even be raised… :’(
[Reply]
The Anonymous Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 6:57 pm
yes, nicely said.
They can simply deny the ad, but not denying it and further accusing some other party (in this context = other religions).
[Reply]
towanikkusu Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 7:05 pm
*Oh, how my heart aches…*
I actually declined posting a link because this debate is rather heated, but I believe this should be of importance for everyone.
http://oh-teh-noes.blogspot.com/2010/09/in-times-like-these-i-am-just-tempted.html
I wrote this post when a friend tweeted me this post from Wanmus. You can imagine how my heart really ached.
[Reply]
Unknown Reply:
September 8th, 2010 at 6:26 pm
Stop being so such an idiot, fool. If you were to say that this ad “something wrong”, then you are worse than a pile of garbage. You should take Towanikkusu’s mindset as a good example.
[Reply]
08 September 2010
Masa 11:14 pm
Let’s leave aside the fact about the nature of this argument. I here by wish all muslims ‘Selamat Hari Raya Aidilfitri’.
[Reply]
08 September 2010
Masa 11:37 pm
Suhweet post. I linked back ! ^_^
[Reply]
09 September 2010
Masa 3:11 am
Why are you guys fighting over trivial stuff like this.
Sigh~
Its stupid.
They way you (Malay/Muslim) guys are defending your religion/race is wrong.
You/we do it while stepping and degrading others.
Have some respect toward others if we want to be respected in equal.
Respect should be earned and from what i see here, there’s no way it can be earned in thousands of years.
Salam
[Reply]
14 September 2010
Masa 3:41 pm
Oh, and what a surprise. *rolls eyes* Not a single soul dared comment on my very first comment ? Even after a week or so ? I’m already of the view that everyone here who agrees with this article realises the bigotry he has just committed. I don’t usually like being harsh, but face it, people. I hand this over to MyConsti and people will cry foul saying this is a sensitive issue. But sensitive issues like these are the things that bring us to ruin.
[Reply]
24 September 2010
Masa 7:46 pm
Asslmualaikum…
salam sejahtera semua..agak sedih membaca komen2 saudara semua.anda patut tahu isu agama itu satu sensitiviti.membincangkannya secara terbuka hanya menyebabkan sesama kita berbalah dan bukannya membawa kebaikan.kita perlulah menghormati agama2 lain jika mahu agama kita dihormati.saya tidak memihak kepada mana2 pihak.hari raya adalah perayaan umat islam.tidak slh jika agama lain ingin menyambutnya bersama.tp anda kena paham konsep sebenar perayaan hari raya itu disambut.hari raya disambut sempena kemenangan umat islam berjuang menahan lapar dahaga dan hawa nafsu sepanjang sebulan berpuasa.tiada kaitan dgn memperingati apa2 peristiwa sejarah islam..mgkin pengarah iklan tu ingin mengetengahkan konsep 1malaysia tp tanpa dia sedari ia telah membangkitkan amarah umat islam.semua ni mgkin 1kebetulan yg dia tidak sedari jd maafkanlah pengarah tu.lgpun tv3 kn dh mnta maaf.jd sudah2la ye.xperlulah nk heboh2.sebaik2 umat adalah memaafkan umat yg lain.wpun perkataan ‘maaf’ tu singkat,percayalah ia membawa seribu makna.janganlah disimpan di dalam hati..untuk penulis blog eloklah anda padamkan post ni
[Reply]
07 October 2011
Masa 8:13 pm
Huhuuu . Islam agamaku . Janganlah kau pesongkan hati aku .
[Reply]